Long Island Custom Cakes, Cupcakes, & Cookies

Making It The Most Trusted Bakery On Long Island

Our Services


“Baked with Butter, Makes It Better” – Here at Buttercooky Bakery we utilize the freshest and finest ingredients available so you can forget about fillers and artificial flavorings!

Our Menu


Birthdays, anniversaries, baby showers, engagements and weddings to name a few: we make cakes for any and all occasions! Check out our gallery for ideas!



Collaborate one-on-one with an experienced member of the team. We will meet with you to create and design a cake that incorporates your ideas and vision.

Meet With Us


Whether you are celebrating the holidays or recognizing a valued relationship Buttercooky Bakery offers a wide selection of pastries perfect for any occasion!

Ask About Catering

Check Out Long Island’s Award-Winning Bakery Gallery

Birthday Cakes



Our Story

Our History

For over 50 years Buttercooky Bakery has served Long Island residents fresh-baked cookies, pastries and cakes. Our flagship store has become a Floral Park fixture and our Manhasset store has been building a following for a decade and counting

Our History

The Baker

Chef Borgognone’s devotion, diligence, authentic recipes, and elegant presentations have allowed Buttercooky Bakery to earn its current high standards nationally and become one of Long Island’s landmarks, as it is known as today.

About The Baker

What’s New

Check out what’s happening at the Bakery… we’re always cooking up something! We offer you an experience that is utterly unique: our techniques, focus on freshness, and approach to the art of pastry make us stand out from the rest.

What’s New


We don’t like to boast, but our customers and clients are our most reliable source for testimonials. We’ve worked hard to create a loyal customer base with our dedication to detail, and it shows in our ratings and reviews!

Our Happy Clients

Buttercooky Bakery Locations

Floral Park, New York

Buttercooky Bakery

217 Jericho Turnpike Floral Park, NY 11001
Phone: 516-354-3831 | Fax: 516-354-7472
Monday – Friday 6:00 AM to 8:00 PM
Saturday 6:00 AM to 8:00 PM
Sunday 7:00 AM to 8:00 PM

Manhasset, New York

Buttercooky Bakery

140 Plandome Road Manhasset, NY 11030
Phone: 516-627-1600 | Fax: 516-627-1692
Monday – Friday 6:00 AM to 8:00 PM
Saturday 7:00 AM to 8:00 PM
Sunday 7:00 AM to 6:00 PM