Buttercooky Bakery | Long Island Custom Cakes, Cupcakes, Cookies2018-10-16T19:03:07+00:00

Everyday Products

See What We Have.

Our Bakery Services

Find Out More

Bakery Locations

Why Wait. Visit Us Now.

Voted The Best Bakery On Long Island. Family-Owned For Over 50 Years.

“As a Pastry Chef, I am in a unique position to translate the world around me into edible art…and when I create a product that totally surpasses my customer’s expectations… that’s when I realize why I do what I do, and I love it!

– Ben Borgognone

See What We’ve Been Baking For You Today…

Wedding Cake Design Center

Welcome to the Buttercooky Bakery’s Wedding Design Center. With over 50 years of baking experience we can design, and deliver the cake of your dreams for your Wedding Day. Book your appointment with our cake specialist to review your cake ideas or if you’re not sure exactly what you want we are ready to walk you through step by step.

Book An Appointment
View Our Cake Gallery

Tradition

Quality

Creativity

Passion

Ordering A Cake From Our Cake Design Center Is As Easy As 1,2,3.

Each one of our locations offers our customers with a personalized one-on-one cake design consultation. From Birthday Cakes to Wedding Cakes we offer you the opportunity to have a one-of-a-kind creation of your dreams. Let us make your dreams come true. We make it simple, affordable and worry-free.

Schedule Tasting
Meet Your Consultant
Event Details

See What Our Dedicated Customers Have To Say About Buttercooky Bakery…

“Best bakery on Long Island by far.”

“What a treat! I’d heard about the wonderful cupcakes Buttercooky creates for kids, but was totally blown away not only by the taste but the beautiful designs. I purchased a couple dozen cupcakes for my nephew’s birthday – he was so happy when he saw them! The parents also were impressed. I highly recommend Buttercooky for those special occasions desserts.”
– Rae D.

CLOSE
CLOSE